Sunday, 10 October 2010

Probables v Possibles

Maybe its because I was born on the day of an All Black trial, but I've always loved the idea of the trial matches. Clearly in the days of amateurism it was a cheeky move on the All Blacks part, a sham that actually gave the squad an extra game together to bond & train under the auspices of being a genuine trial. The truth was in the names of the teams, and as this was in the days before the now ubiquitous use of words like 'bolter' I doubt many Possibles got through over the years at the expense of an outplayed Probable.

So, what if we held a Trial now for the upcoming Northern gimmick Grand Slam tour? On the back of some extremely high quality rugby throughout the ITM Cup so far, who would make up Henry-Smith-Hansen's favoured XV? ... And who have they got their eyes on? Below is my twenty cents worth.


Mils Muliaina, Corey Jane, Josevata Rokococo, Conrad Smith, Ma'a Nonu, Aaron Cruden, Piri Weepu, Kieran Read, Richie McCaw (c), Jerome Kaino, Brad Thorne, Tom Donnelly, Tony Woodcock, Kevin Mealamu, Owen Franks

Reserves: Benson Stanley, Rene Ranger, Alby Matthewson, Aled de Malmanche, Victor Vito, Ben Afeaki, Anthony Boric

Israel Dagg, Hosea Gear, Sitiveni Sivivatu, Robbie Fruean, Sonny Bill Williams, Daniel Carter, Jimmy Cowan, Colin Bourke, Liam Messam (c), Tanerau Latimer, Josh Bekhuis, Sam Whitelock, Ben Franks, Jason Routledge, John Afoa

Reserves: Isiah Toeava, Tyson Keats, Colin Slade, Daniel Braid, Luke Romano, Hikwera Elliot, Neemia Tialata

WTF? Well, Carter plays because he needs a game. Richie plays because he'd probably want to. Clearly, there are a few fringe/injured All Black capped players ... Luke McAlister, Richard Kahui, Corey Flynn, Andrew Hore, Adam Thompson, Brendon Leonard out of the running for now

I'd run Cruden with the Probable backs, and give Slade at least 40 mins with the Possibles, maybe more. SBW and Fruean go together ... a mouth-watering mid-field pair for the future. The rest are either players already bedded in the wider squad, and a few of my perceived stand-outs from the ITM so far. Everyone loves a bolter, eh?
And as its an unofficial non-IRB match, maybe we should slip a couple more onto the benches, some extra 10s to try out? Taine Randell reckons we should even leave McCaw and Carter out completely and is pretty keen on having another look at Mike Delany. And remember that guy Stephen Donald? Honestly, I think our perceived lack of depth is immaterial: it sells papers and jams talkback switchboards. We are looking good after a stellar Tri Nations, but our Test match depth in terms of blooded players still needs to morph into true big match experience. Any team can struggle in a World Cup match, and we still might ... but I think we are going to see a few new All Blacks, and certainly a tonne of new stars in Super Rugby during 2011.

This was way harder than I thought it would be. All Black coaching job anyone? Pass.

Tough luck Southland on the Ranfurly Shield loss: it may not have been the longest reign, but I think it will be remembered for really putting some life back into its prestige, and creating some new folk heroes like Jason Routledge, Jamie McKintosh and Kenny Lynn. What a ride!

Oh, and Ferdy ... nice extra nail driven into Manawatu's coffin by your Taranaki boys yesterday. Thanks. Needed that.


Ben Lee said...

Hi there,

I hope you are well and looking forward to the autumn internationals as much as we are!

I work for Betfair affiliates and with the boxing competition drawing towards its exciting climax I thought now would be a good time to approach you. As your site ranks well on Google under rugby search terms you will clearly be receiving a high amount of traffic over the coming month and you can profit from this traffic by signing up for an affiliate account with Betfair.

We have a wide range of banners and text links to suit your requirements, all of which have proven popular with current and potential bettors; and I think your site would make a great partner for Betfair.
In order to maximise your earnings we are offering you 50%-70% revenue share for 3 months and as our commission is cross tracked we are offering this promotional revenue share across all Betfair products! As an alternative we can offer you CPA ranging from £30 to £40. You will also get direct access to a dedicated Account Manager who will be available to answer all your questions.

I'm really looking forward to hearing back from you with your thoughts on our offer and start working together, or, if you'd like to get signed up straight away follow this link and let me know so that I can get you on the bespoke commission plan.

Kind regards
Ben Lee

Ben Lee
Affiliate Executive

Office: +44 113 207 9288

Scotty said...

I love this concept of a Possibles vs Probables match up. Who said there is no depth in New Zealand rugby? I think that although the rest and rotation policy was heavily criticised in the past, it has helped us develop plenty of depth. Just look at our first fives we now have. We can afford to leave out Slade and Cruden.